The harness vs collar debate continues among dog owners and trainers. Here’s what veterinarians and certified dog trainers recommend based on your dog’s needs…
When to Choose a Harness
- Pullers: Harnesses reduce trachea pressure
- Small dogs: Protects delicate necks (under 25 lbs)
- Flat-faced breeds: Pugs, bulldogs need airway protection
- Neck injuries: Previous trachea or spine issues
When Collars Work Better
- Well-trained dogs: No pulling issues
- Quick potty breaks: Easier to put on
- ID tags: Always visible identification
- Training: Better communication for some methods
Safety Considerations
Collars: Can cause tracheal damage in pullers, not recommended for brachycephalic breeds
Harnesses: May encourage pulling if not fitted properly, can cause chafing
Our Recommendation
Use both! A collar with ID tags for safety, and a harness for walks and training. This gives you the benefits of both while minimizing risks.
