BarkBox vs Super Chewer: Which Subscription Box is Right for Your Dog?
Looking to treat your dog every month with fun toys and tasty chews — but unsure whether BarkBox or Super Chewer is the better pick? We’ve tested both, reviewed user feedback, analyzed pricing, and compared durability so you can choose the perfect subscription for your pup. If your dog is a power chewer, go with Super Chewer — the toys are tough, long-lasting, and backed by a no-questions-asked replacement policy. Below, you’ll find our full verdict, a side-by-side comparison, and which box is best for your dog’s chewing style.
🏆 Top Picks at a Glance
Best for Tough Chewers: Super Chewer – Rugged, fluff-free toys with unbeatable durability and a stellar replacement guarantee
Best for Gentle Dogs: BarkBox – Soft, squeaky plush toys and treats at a more budget-friendly price
Best Overall Value: Super Chewer (12-month plan) – Six high-quality items for $30/month
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Sizes Available | Standout Feature | Free Replacement? | See Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BarkBox | Gentle to average chewers | Small, Medium, Large | Plush toys + fun monthly themes | ✔️ | See price |
| Super Chewer | Heavy/aggressive chewers | Small, Medium, Large | Durable rubber & nylon toys + 2 chews | ✔️ No-questions-asked | See price |
📋 How to Choose the Right Subscription Box
- Chewing strength – Does your dog destroy toys quickly?
- Play style – Plush squeakers vs. durable rubber chews
- Sensitivity – Any allergies or dietary preferences?
- Budget – Monthly vs. annual plan costs vary significantly
📦 Detailed Reviews
Super Chewer – Best for Tough Chewers
If your dog rips through most toys in minutes, Super Chewer is a game-changer. Each monthly box includes two ultra-durable toys (rubber, nylon, or ballistic fabric), two meaty chews, and two full-size treat bags. The standout feature? Their 100% satisfaction guarantee — if your dog breaks a toy, they’ll replace it, no questions asked. Reviewers rave about toy longevity and variety, noting these toys often outlast anything from big-box pet stores.
Pros
- Extra tough materials
- Two chews per box
- Great for power chewers
- No-questions-asked replacement
Cons
- Slightly higher price
- Not ideal for soft toy lovers
Verdict: Built for aggressive chewers who destroy everything else.
See Super Chewer Deals
BarkBox – Best for Gentle or Average Chewers
BarkBox delivers fun and flair for dogs who prefer squeaky, plush, or cuddly toys. Each box includes two toys, two treat bags, and a chew — all wrapped in a clever monthly theme like “Barkcheology” or “Galapawgos Island.” It’s also more budget-friendly, especially with longer subscriptions. That said, tough chewers may shred plush toys quickly, even with BarkBox’s “chewer” upgrades. The good news? Their guarantee will replace anything that doesn’t hold up.
Pros
- Adorable themes
- Great for soft toy lovers
- Lower cost plans
- Good treat quality
Cons
- Not built for strong chewers
- Fewer items than Super Chewer
Verdict: Best for dogs who play gently and love plush toys.
Check BarkBox Pricing
🔁 What’s Included in Each Box?
- BarkBox: 2 plush toys, 2 treat bags, 1 chew
- Super Chewer: 2 durable toys, 2 treat bags, 2 chews
- Both boxes follow fun monthly themes and allow allergy customization
- Shipping is $5 per box — or free if you add extra items
🧠 Real-World Reviews & Customer Feedback
- Owners say Super Chewer toys “last way longer than anything from Target or PetSmart”
- BarkBox fans love the surprise themes and personalized notes
- Common issues: auto-renewal confusion, delayed shipping, or tough cancellation policies
- Overall satisfaction is high for both, especially with longer plans
💡 Value Breakdown
- Super Chewer: 6 items → ~$5–$7 per item (12-month plan = best value)
- BarkBox: 5 items → ~$4.60–$7 per item
- Both claim box value of $44+ based on retail pricing
✅ Final Recommendation
If your dog is a heavy chewer or you’re tired of buying toys that don’t last, Super Chewer is hands-down the better investment. It offers more value per box, unbeatable durability, and a generous replacement policy that sets it apart from every other dog box we’ve tested.
But if your dog prefers soft squeaky toys and you want a lower-cost option, BarkBox is still a great pick — especially if you sign up for a longer-term plan.
Either way, you’re getting themed boxes of joy every month — and your dog will love you for it.
Ready to surprise your pup? Pick your box below and enjoy exclusive offers:
🎁 Try Super Chewer – Best for Tough Dogs
🐾 Try BarkBox – Best for Gentle Pups
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch from BarkBox to Super Chewer?
Yes — you can contact BARK’s customer support to switch boxes mid-subscription.
What if my dog destroys a toy quickly?
Both services offer a guarantee. Super Chewer’s is especially generous: no questions asked, no photos needed.
Are there options for allergies?
Yes! Both boxes let you exclude common allergens like chicken, beef, or turkey.
What if my dog doesn’t like the treats?
Contact their team — they’ll often send replacements or adjust future boxes.
Is it worth the price?
If you usually buy toys and treats monthly, these boxes are often cheaper than buying individually — and way more fun.
📝 Final Thoughts
We’ve compared every detail — from toy durability to pricing to real customer feedback. Our verdict: Super Chewer wins for most dog owners thanks to longer-lasting toys, better value per item, and top-notch customer service. But BarkBox still shines for plush toy lovers who enjoy the monthly surprise and softer play.
Choose based on your dog’s chew style — and don’t forget to lock in the best deal below.
